DonAithnen (donaithnen) wrote,
DonAithnen
donaithnen

  • Mood:

VCA Contest Results

The VCA contest wrapped up last week. If you've got an account you can see the results here. As expected, two well done videos that i personally did not appreciate from an artistic viewpoint managed to sweep up 7 awards between them. but a couple of videos i liked managed to sneak through. So how good a job did i do at influencing the outcome?

Best Action:
Nominees: Voted for: 2, Favorites: 2
Winner: Not a favorite

Best Character:
Nominees: Voted for: 1, Favorites: 3
Winner: Not a favorite

Best Collaborative Video
Nominees: Voted for: 2, Favorites: 2
Winner: Favorite, but not the one i voted for

Best Comedy Video
Nominees: Voted for: 1, Favorites: 3
Winner: Favorite, but not the one i voted for

Best Dance Video
Nominees: Voted for: 2, Favorites: 2
Winner: Not a favorite

Best Dramatic Video
Nominees: Voted for: 3, Favorites: 3
Winner: Favorite, but not the one i voted for

Best First Video
Nominees: Voted for: 2, Favorites: 2
Winner: The one i voted for!

Best Fun Video
Nominees: Voted for:0, Favorites: 3
Winner: Favorite, but not the one i voted for

Best Horror Video
Nominees: Voted for: 0, Favorites: 0
Winner: Not even remotely a favorite


Best Multi-Editor Project
Nominees: Voted for: 2, Favorites: 2
Winner: Not a favorite

Best Parody Video
Nominees: Voted for: 1, Favorites: 1
Winner: The one i voted for!

Best Romantic Video
Nominees: Voted for: 1, Favorites: 2
Winner: Not a favorite

Best Sentimental Video
Nominees: Voted for: 1, Favorites: 2
Winner: The one i voted for!

Best Short Video
Nominees: Voted for: 3, Favorites: 3
Winner: The one i voted for!

Best Storytelling
Nominees: Voted for: 2, Favorites: 2
Winner: Not a favorite

Best Trailer or Commercial
Nominees: Voted for: 2, Favorites: 2
Winner: Not a favorite

Best Use of Instrumental Music
Nominees: Voted for: 3, Favorites: 2
Winner: One of my nominees, but not the one i voted for and not really a favorite

Best Use of Lip Synch
Nominees: Voted for: 3, Favorites: 3
Winner: Not a favorite

Best Use of Multiple Anime
Nominees: Voted for: 2, Favorites: 3
Winner: Favorite, but not the one i voted for

Best Use of Single Anime
Nominees: Voted for: 3, Favorites: 3
Winner: Not a favorite

Best Use of Special Effects
Nominees: Voted for: 2, Favorites: 2
Winner: Not a favorite

Most Artistic Video
Nominees: Voted for: 3, Favorites: 2
Winner: Not a favorite

Most Original Video
Nominees: Voted for: 3, Favorites: 2
Winner: Not a favorite

Video of the Year
Nominees: Voted for: 1, Favorites: 1
Winner: Not a favorite

I think it's worth reiterating, especially in this context, that just because a video wasn't my favourtie doesn't mean it was bad. The two the cleaned up at the awards were _very_ well done, i was just personally annoyed by some of the themes and source material.

But in any case, the videos i really liked went on to the finalist round in 53/120 cases, or about 44%. The videos i _voted_ for went on to the finalist round in 44/120 cases, or about 37%. The reason for the disparity is that in many categories there were more videos that i liked than slots i could nominate for. So in many cases what would have been my #6 choice or #7 choice or etc made it in.

As far as actually winning goes, videos that i really liked made it in 9/24 cases, or about 37%, and the ones i voted for won in 4/24 cases, or about 17%.

But wait! There's more! There were also the editor categories!

Editor of the Year
Nominees: Voted for: 2
Winner: Not a favorite

Most Helpful Member
Nominees: Voted for: 3
Winner: The one i voted for!

Most Improved Editor
Nominees: Voted for: 3
Winner: The one i voted for!

Rookie of the Year
Nominees: Voted for: 2
Winner: The one i voted for!

So for some reason i rocked in the editor section! I voted for 10 of the 20 nominees and 3 of the 4 winners! So 50% and 75% success rate!

Interestingly, if you eliminate the categories in which the two stellar videos won, then my "favorites got nominated" rate stays steady at about 45%, while the "voted for nominees" rate actually _drops_ to 32%. However as expected the "one of my favorites won" and "voted for the winner" values skyrocket to 53% and 23% respectively. But obviously if i had the magical power to dictate the categories and/or results then very quickly my success rate would shoot to 100% :)
Tags: amvs, anime
Subscribe
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 0 comments